By David Pendered
Metro Atlanta’s prospects for winning Amazon’s second headquarters may have been dinged by a report from the Brookings Institution that highlighted the region’s comparative scarcity of college-educated millennials. Baltimore officials think their city may have lost out for that very reason.
Unlike Atlanta, Baltimore didn’t make Amazon’s list of 20 cities that remain contenders for its HQ2. Amazon hinted that Baltimore’s labor force may have been a concern, according to a Feb. 14 report by WBAL-TV that quoted Bill Cole, president of the Baltimore Development Corp.:
- “What we have heard repeatedly from them both in our exit call is that they are looking for a place that is tech-talent ready to go on day one. … They never said that specifically in our call. What they said was, ‘You need to keep doing what you are doing to grow tech talent, focusing on STEM education, keep working with Johns Hopkins (University) to endure. You have tech talent in the region.'”
The role in Amazon’s decision of Baltimore’s crime rate – the highest per capita murder rate in the country, according to a Feb. 19 report by usatoday.com – is unknown, Cole said: “They just went right around that question,” he told WBAL-TV.
The Brookings report, released Feb. 7, sought to address the question posed in the title of the report: Where do the most educated millennials live? Are they living in the Amazon HQ2 finalist places?
Metro Atlanta ranked 12th out of the 16 metro regions that made Amazon’s shortlist and are ranked among Brookings’ 100 largest metro areas with the highest and lowest percentages of college graduates among the millennial generation – defined as 25 years to 34 years of age.
The report determined that 39 percent of metro Atlanta residents in this age group have been graduated from college.
The top five regions, in terms of the proportion of college graduates, that made Amazon’s Top 20 list are:
- Boston – 58.5 percent;
- Washington – 53.6 percent;
- New York – 47.5 percent;
- Raleigh – 47.2 percent;
- Minneapolis – 46.9 percent.
The regions that ranked below metro Atlanta and still made Amazon’s list are:
- Indianapolis – 36.4 percent;
- Los Angeles – 34.8 percent;
- Dallas – 34.8 percent;
- Miami – 32.2 percent.
Although educational attainment is a factor for Amazon, the author of the Brookings report reminds that education is just one of many factors Amazon is considering. The company provided its wish list in its request for proposals.
For instance, Baltimore is ranked 18th on the proportion of college graduates who are millennials, at 42.5 percent. That compares to 27th-ranked metro Atlanta, with its 39 percent college graduation rate.
As the report’s author, William Frey, a senior fellow in Brookings’ Metropolitan Policy Program, observed:
- “[W]hile millennial education was likely an important element in the consideration of Amazon HQ2 finalists, an examination of these locales suggests it was not the only condition for their advancement in the competition. …
- “Clearly, the Amazon finalists are skewed toward places with very high concentrations of college graduate millennials. However, other such places were passed over, presumably in the quest for different qualities.”
At this point, a report by CNBC weighs in on another area where metro Atlanta may be dinged – acceptance of diversity. The story that posted Feb. 23 puts it right there in the first paragraph:
- “Georgia’s Senate passed a bill Friday that won’t necessarily help Atlanta’s chances of landing Amazon HQ2, the second North American headquarters for the technology giant that 20 metro areas are vying for with a decision expected from Amazon by year end.”
The story referred to Senate Bill 375, titled the, Keep Faith in Adoption and Foster Care Act. The bill authorizes taxpayer funded adoption agencies to decline referrals on the grounds of, “sincerely held religious beliefs.”
The story observes that advocates say the measure aims to encourage adoption agencies to open in Georgia. The story quotes GLAAD’s president and CEO, Sarah Kate Ellis, who criticized the legislation in a statement:
- “This bill is not about freedom of religion, which is one of our nation’s fundamental values, but rather about imposing one’s personal religious beliefs on others to discriminate against loving foster or adoptive parents simply because of their identity and deny services to LGBTQ youth.”
The House had not referred the bill to committee as of midday Monday.