,

Atlanta leaders see what drives Motor City during 2017 LINK trip

By Maria Saporta
As published in the Atlanta Business Chronicle on May 19, 2017

Note to readers: The 2017 LINK trip was the 21st annual trip, which began in 1997. Hundreds of regional leaders have been invited to participate on the LINK trips, which have visited Denver (twice), Dallas (twice), Seattle (twice), Chicago, Boston, San Francisco, Houston, Toronto, Vancouver, San Diego, Portland, Miami, Minneapolis-St. Paul, Cleveland, Philadelphia, Phoenix and Washington, D.C.

DETROIT — Metro Atlanta’s problems seem miniscule when compared to the challenges Michigan’s largest city has faced in recent years.

About 130 leaders from the Atlanta region spent the better part of three days learning about the ups and downs of Detroit on the annual LINK trip from May 3 to May 6 — seeking insights they could bring back home.

Impressed by the candor of people in Detroit, Atlantans heard firsthand from leaders how the city has emerged from the largest municipal bankruptcy in U.S. history (filed in July 2013) following the conviction of Mayor Kwame Kilpatrick in 2008 on multiple felony counts.

LINK 2017

Renaissance Center was designed by Atlanta’s own – John Portman. It was viewed as a downtown fortress when it was built, but now it has become a symbol of Detroit, which has kept many of its historic buildings (Photo by Maria Saporta)

Speakers described how the population in the City of Detroit fell from a peak of 1.8 million in the 1950s to less than 800,000 today. It lost 108,000 jobs between 1998 and 2006, and unemployment hit 25 percent between 2010 and 2012.

“We got the pleasure of going into the recession about two years earlier than the rest of the country,” said Tom Lewand, CEO of Detroit-based Shinola, a growing manufacturing company that makes watches, bicycles, turntables and small leather goods.

“Detroit was sorely in need of putting people back to work,” Lewand added. “We are proud to say we are from Detroit. Our heritage is manufacturing.”

Despite the multiple obstacles Detroit has faced, Atlantans found a passionate, grassroots pride among leaders in Detroit intent on finding ways to rebuild their city. “There’s a lot of hope here and a lot of hustle,” said Erica Raleigh, director of Data Driven Detroit, who said the city and the suburbs don’t work well together. “For decades, we were all-out competing against each other. We would do better if we weren’t stealing businesses from one another.”

The city’s bankruptcy, described by some as “the best thing that happened to us,” forced philanthropic, business and government leaders to work together.

“The media in the United States and the world were writing this city’s obituary,” said Judge Gerald Rosen, who helped put together the Grand Bargain that permitted Detroit to keep its famed art collection as well as cover about 95 percent of the city’s pension obligations.

Despite accusations the city was placing art above people, Rosen said Detroit would not have survived if the city had liquidated its museum and its arts collection.

“We would have put an exclamation point on our obituary,” Rosen said.

LINK 2017

A sign at the Campus Martius Park downtown says it all – Quicken Loans, and its founder Dan Gilbert – have been investing in downtown Detroit real estate and moving jobs to the city (Photo by Maria Saporta)

The Ford Foundation gave $125 million and the Kresge Foundation gave $200 million to help towards the Grand Bargain, which served as a “reset” button for the city.

“As a child, I remember Detroit in its greatness,” Mayor Mike Duggan told the Atlanta delegation during a dinner at the Detroit Institute of Arts surrounded by murals of Diego Rivera. “Detroit is going to come back.”

Duggan had been living in the suburbs and decided to run for mayor as a write-in candidate in a city with a black population of 80 percent. For those wondering how Detroit elected “someone who looks like me” as mayor, Duggan said he built support from the ground up by sitting down with people in their homes.

“We have let us-versus-them politics tear us down,” said Duggan, who is running for re-election and has built city-wide support. “We still have the highest unemployment rates in Michigan. We still have blight. But wherever we are going, we are going there unified.”

Detroit has launched several initiatives to get people to move back to the central city, including Live Detroit. Major employers encourage their workers to live close by. Because there is not a regional transit system, it is difficult for the urban poor to get jobs in the suburbs and vice-versa.

A regional bus transit referendum failed last November by only 17,000 votes, and leaders are hopeful the gulf between the city and the suburbs is narrowing.

LINK 2017

Group shot in the Guardian building (Photo by Ian McCain of the Detroit Experience Factory)

But public education continues to be a weak point. “Detroit is the lowest academically performing city in the nation,” said Tonya Allen, president of the Skillman Foundation.

Alycia Meriweather, the interim superintendent of the Detroit Public Schools Community District, said 60 percent of its students live at or below the poverty line — which is a family of four living on a $24,000 annual income. She made the distinction between “equal” — where everybody gets the same; and “equity” — where everybody gets what they need.

“We do lead with race and equity in almost every conversation,” said Maurice Cox, Detroit’s planning commissioner.

“We are embarking on a fairly unique urban experience,” Cox added. “We are embarking on an equitable recovery.” In other words, Detroit is committed to growing its population without displacing the people who stuck with the city. “Let’s plan with them. We are about deep, deep engagement with zero displacement.”

Cox said the city is plagued with acres and acres of blighted and vacant properties.

“We’ve been trying to figure out what happens when 1.2 million people leave and leave their buildings behind,” he said. “We have 60 schools that are vacant.”

Detroit demolishes about 200 houses a week, and it still has a backlog of dilapidated structures.

LINK 2017 Maurice Cox

Detroit planning commissioner Vincent Cox talks to Bill Bolling and Alicia Philipp as Doug Hooker and Albert Edwards look on (Photo by Maria Saporta)

“My job is to find a new purpose for the land in the city,” Cox said. “We are moving from renovating one house at a time to one block at a time to one neighborhood at a time.”

Detroit currently has seven urban redevelopment experiments underway. One is turning 300 lots into gardens and urban farms. It is creating a “green collar” industry to give people training on urban agriculture and other businesses.

“We are trying to restore the authenticity of a working-class neighborhood in Detroit,” Cox said.

Because it was built to house a much larger population with many highways, Detroit doesn’t have the traffic problems Atlanta has. But even its Big Three auto manufacturers are having to contemplate a future with autonomous cars and more transportation alternatives with less parking.

And because the city was losing population, it did not lose many of its historic buildings to development. Several Atlanta developers described Detroit as “having great bones.”

Kevin Greiner, president and CEO of Gas South, said he was struck by how Detroit was focused on what’s equitable, a conversation he hoped “we can take back to Atlanta.”

LINK 2017 Elena Parent

State Sen. Elena Parent reflects on her first LINK trip (Photo by Maria Saporta)

Georgia State Sen. Elena Parent, who was on her first LINK trip, said she was inspired by Detroit’s candid discussions on race and class.

And Doug Hooker, director of the Atlanta Regional Commission, which organizes the trip, summed up Detroit as a “place that grows on you,” and he described the resiliency of its people as “inspiring.”

Daniel Kaufman, president and CEO of the Gwinnett Chamber of Commerce, said education remains Detroit’s greatest obstacle among the many it faces.

“They have rescued Detroit, but they haven’t saved it,” Kaufman said. “The good news is that downtown and Midtown are vibrant. They have to attract young professionals, entrepreneurs and taxpayers into the city.

“They are where Atlanta was 30 years ago — a black core surrounded by white suburbs,” Kaufman continued. “We have integrated ourselves in both directions. Our suburbs are more diverse and we have an urban core that is vibrant.”

LINK 2017

LINK delegation has dinner inside the great hall at the Detroit Institute of Arts surrounded by Diego Rivera murals (Photo by Michael Halicki)

 

LINK 2017

Detroit Mayor Mike Duggan addresses the LINK delegation (Photo by Michael Halicki)

 

LINK 2017

LINK delegation visited the Ford Rouge Factor in Dearborn, Michigan where they learned about the origins of Detroit’s automobile industry (Photo by Maria Saporta)

LINK 2017 Charlotte Nash Wayne Hill

LINK 2017 had two concurrent groups – the regular LINK delegation and LINK Forward (which invited seasoned leaders to have a more indepth experience. That brought together old friends – Gwinnett Commission Chair Charlotte Nash and former Gwinnett Commission Chair Wayne Hill (Photo by Maria Saporta)

LINK 2017

LINK delegation broke off into groups – this one explored downtown and Midtown Detroit touring the Guardian building (Photo by Maria Saporta)

 

LINK 2017

The Guardian building (Photo by Maria Saporta)

Maria Saporta, Editor, is a longtime Atlanta business, civic and urban affairs journalist with a deep knowledge of our city, our region and state.  Since 2008, she has written a weekly column and news stories for the Atlanta Business Chronicle. Prior to that, she spent 27 years with The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, becoming its business columnist in 1991. Maria received her Master’s degree in urban studies from Georgia State and her Bachelor’s degree in journalism from Boston University. Maria was born in Atlanta to European parents and has two young adult children.

1 reply
  1. Burroughston Broch says:

    Reality: The Detroit city core has been resuscitated by big money while the remainder of the city continues to rot. Hamtramck and Highland Park continue to rot. Most of the suburbs, including Windsor, Ontario, are holding their own.Report

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

What are your thoughts?