Crum & Forster building – Court order preserves a third, rest to be razed
By David Pendered
The front third of the Crum & Forster building in Midtown will be saved, and the rest of the building razed, according to a consent order signed Tuesday by Fulton Superior Court Judge John Goger.
These terms were reached Tuesday in an amended consent order negotiated by lawyers for the Georgia Tech Foundation and two defendants – the city of Atlanta and its Board of Zoning Appeals. The ruling appears to end a preservation battle that has raged since GTF filed a request for a demolition permit in April 2008.
Goger denied a motion to allow five interveners in the case, a ruling that affirmed a comment from a lawyer for the city who said all concerns of the proposed interveners were resolved by the consent agreement.
The five were represented by Mary Carol Cooney, a former deputy city attorney. Their possible next steps were not clear immediately after the ruling.
The consent order instructs the Board of Zoning Appeals to vote at its next regularly scheduled meeting “to render a decision consistent with the findings herein.” The BZA declined in November to vote for a consent agreement reached in September.
If the BZA declines to comply with the new agreement within 60 days of the order being signed, GTF may file an objection and the court instructed that it shall have all remedies available for enforcement, “including its contempt powers.”
Cooney had contended, during her oral argument, that the decision to preserve any of the building was reached only because of the presence of the proposed interveners.
Goger indicated he was ready for the matter to be resolved: “This case … has gone on way too long.”
The consent order provides a fair amount of history behind the case. The nine-page order includes a site plan that shows a sketch of the parts of the building to be demolished, the part to be preserved, and the fences to be erected to protect trees.
The property is considered part of Georgia Tech’s signature development, Tech Square. Tech wants to build a computer center on the block.
Click here to read Maria Saporta’s account of the intriguing context of the battle.