Enough already: Time for City of Atlanta, Atlanta BeltLine and APS to reach a deal

By Maria Saporta

It’s gone on long enough.

The political and legal dispute between the City of Atlanta and the Atlanta Public Schools over how much the Atlanta BeltLine owes the school system is going into its third year.

As long as the negotiations are left in the hands of political leaders who dislike each other and shun any perception that the other side has “won,” we all lose.

Never has this breakdown been more apparent (or disturbing) than at the APS “State of the District” rally at the David T. Howard gym on Oct. 8.

Meria Carstarphen

Superintendent Meria Carstarphen addresses a packed gym at the David T. Howard school (Photo by Maria Saporta)

Superintendent Meria Carstarphen passionately presented the challenge before us. Atlanta’s public schools are not performing at an acceptable level – in fact, 26 schools could be at risk of being taken over by the state because of of low performance.

That is not acceptable, she said. Every one in the community must rally behind a common goal: to make sure every school and every child has access to a quality education in the City of Atlanta.

To reach that goal will require bold, sometimes painful, steps to reverse the course Atlanta has been on.

“I will not be able to do this job alone,” Carstarphen insisted. It will require the work and attention of the entire community – not just those involved with Atlanta Public Schools.

“We won’t have time to fight,” said Carstarphen, a comment that could have been directed to City Hall, APS parents and staff or any number of vested interests.

“The problems are so entrenched and the runway is so short, we will have to consider bold actions so we can get relief from long-standing failures.”

Howard history

People tour David T. Howard school, which has been closed since 1976 (Photo by Maria Saporta)

The alternative?

“If we continue the path we have been on, we are not going to be able do it,” she said. “Atlanta needs a quality public school system so the city can be as successful as it can be. But it can’t be successful for some children – it has to be successful for all its children.”

When asked directly about the legal and political stand-off between APS and the City of Atlanta, Carstarphen clearly was uncomfortable.

“I don’t have to tell you how difficult it is,” she said. “We have to make sure district ship and the city ship are going in the same direction so they don’t collide in the night. We still need to get to work. That strategy is going to need to work.”

No world-class city can have a true renaissance without healthy public schools. It is beyond ridiculous to have a city government at odds with its public school system. The two entities should be partners – working hand-in-hand to make both the city and its schools better for all.

And this should not be portrayed as a choice between APS and the Atlanta BeltLine.

Howard renovation

How a renovated Howard School would look like (Special: APS)

Again, strong public schools help strengthen the foundation of our city. And the Atlanta BeltLine is one reason the city has the forward-looking energy it has. No agreement should be made that would put the Atlanta BeltLine in jeopardy. At the same time, no agreement should short-change APS.

But most importantly, we as a city – that includes all of us taxpayers who want strong schools, a robust BeltLine and a thriving city – can not sit on the sidelines waiting for our political leaders and their legal teams to work this out.

They have had years to try to find a solution, and they have come up short. Each side will say the other side has moved the finish line just when an agreement was within reach.

It really doesn’t matter. Until a consensus has been found, every one is to blame for this divide.

And the clock is ticking. If an agreement is not reached by the end of the year, the City and the BeltLine will owe APS yet another multi-million dollar payment – making a solution even harder to negotiate.

Howard gym

A look at the Howard gym today (Photo by Maria Saporta)

From my perspective, it is time to get the politicians out of the way and to bring in a mediator or a mediation panel to work out a compromise. Business and civic leaders should use their power and influence to demand no less – because the status quo is hurting us all.

Interestingly enough, the State of the District rally was held at the David T. Howard school, closed since 1976. APS wants to renovate and reopen as a middle school so it can handle all the students who want to enroll in the successful Grady High School cluster.

That is directly attributable to what Carstarphen called the “re-urbanization” of Atlanta – evidence that more families want to enjoy an urban lifestyle.

The symbolism is strong. This is the school where Maynard Jackson, Vernon Jordan, Martin Luther King Jr., Hattie Dorsey, Walt Frazier and Herman Russell once attended. These leaders made Atlanta the great city it is today.

But for that to happen, APS would need to have voters renew the SPLOST (one penny sales tax) – an effort that would need broad support.

Howard gym

A look at the Howard gym after renovation (Special: APS)

On the southwest part of town, in Adair Park, stands another school that’s been vacant since the mid 1970s – the George Adair School. APS had an agreement to sell the historic school (two blocks from the BeltLine) to a developer who would have renovated it and turned it into residences.

But Mayor Kasim Reed refused to turn over the deed of the school to APS thereby denying Adair Park the largest private development boost it would have enjoyed in decades. The reason? The mayor said the City has to have a deal with APS first before it will hand over the deed.

So every one loses – APS, the City of Atlanta and the BeltLine.
When pressed about APS’ relationship with the city, Carstarphen called it “still strained and challenged,” adding that she hoped to get “those things off our plate” so APS could focus its students.

We would be so much better off if the City, the Atlanta BeltLine and APS were rowing in unison to improve our schools, revive our communities while welcoming new e the residents throughout the city.

“I know Atlanta can do it,” Carstarphen said. “When people in Atlanta come together, they can make some pretty amazing magic happen.”

Meria Carstarphen

Meria Carstarphen answers questions from reporters in front the Howard School (Photo by Maria Saporta)

David T. Howard School

A view of David T. Howard School, which APS would like to renovate and turn into a middle school (Photo by Maria Saporta)

Maria Saporta, Editor, is a longtime Atlanta business, civic and urban affairs journalist with a deep knowledge of our city, our region and state.  Since 2008, she has written a weekly column and news stories for the Atlanta Business Chronicle. Prior to that, she spent 27 years with The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, becoming its business columnist in 1991. Maria received her Master’s degree in urban studies from Georgia State and her Bachelor’s degree in journalism from Boston University. Maria was born in Atlanta to European parents and has two young adult children.

15 replies
  1. Burroughston Broch says:

    The amount of money in dispute, although sizable, is but  a small part of APS’ bloated budget, the highest per pupil in the State. The Superintendent is already looking for excuses for poor performance.Report

    Reply
  2. JWK says:

    I agree that the APS budget is bloated and that situation must be addressed as well as the disproportionate headcount at 55 Trinity.
    However, if there is an existing contract between the City and APS, the City needs to honor the terms, get up to date on the payments in question and then work toward renegotiating the contract. Mayor Reed must think all contracts are handled the same way as in professional sports. He is extremely fortunate that APS has not yet completely stopped all work on the Beltline and put a lien on any and all assets in question. It is very easy to determine who is at fault in this case and the childish behavior needs to stop immediately. And as for the statement “not willing to negotiate at gunpoint”, if you pay your Creditors it is not necessary.Report

    Reply
  3. Living the Dream says:

    So what are you saying Burroughston Broch ?  That the Mayor has the right to hold the contractually agreed money because you and the mayor don’t agree with the APS Budget?  The Superintendent is cutting headcount at APS.  What is the bloated (and extremely non-transparent) city doing?  Remember, Atlanta got an “F” for spending transparency, whereas Chicago and NYC got an “A”.Report

    Reply
  4. Living the Dream says:

    So what are you saying Burroughston Broch ?  That the Mayor has the right to hold the contractually agreed money because you and the mayor don’t agree with the APS Budget?  The Superintendent is cutting headcount at APS.  What is the bloated (and extremely non-transparent) city doing?  Remember, Atlanta got an “F” for spending transparency, whereas Chicago and NYC got an “A”.Report

    Reply
  5. Guest says:

    Maria, there IS a deal already in place. The fact that the idiot Kasim does not like it is just tough shit. I hope this goes to Court, so that everyone will finally understand the true fool that IS Kasim Reed.Report

    Reply
  6. Burroughston Broch says:

    @Grow Up Everyone Burroughston Broch  I obviously did not express myself fully. I have no respect for His Dishonor and do not support the City’s position in this matter. They are beyond shameless.
    Nevertheless, the amount of money involved does not justify the APS Superintendent’s excuses.
    As my mother said, “A pox on both their houses.” It is a shame City taxpayers are saddled with such charlatans year after year.Report

    Reply
  7. Angela Hale says:

    Meria needs support. Seems like the choices are win-win or lose-lose. Whether this standoff is about ego, turf, or glory — Atlanta families need collaboration and not a game of chicken.Report

    Reply
  8. Phil Lunney says:

    I agree with Ms. Carstarphen and I think part of the solution is the title to the Adair Park property. For a couple of the properties I would suggest turning them into Construction Projects run as an ‘inner city’ workers’ outreach run by Metropolitan Technical College with assistance of the TCSG – Technical College System of Georgia . Turn at least 2 old schools into Senior Housing for homeowners and renters who will be ‘put out’ by the coming ‘gentrification’.
    In this way, we can train current Atlanta residents building skills; provide a display of “What a Great City can do”; settle the reimbursement to include the value of the Adair Park property.Report

    Reply
  9. mnst says:

    @Grow Up Everyone That’s the first time in the history of the Atlanta internet that Burroughston Broch has been accused of shilling for the Mayor — I got a nice laugh out of that one!Report

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

What are your thoughts?

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.