Free ATL Streetcar rides make economic sense

Original Story by Maria Saporta on WABE

Play Audio

The Atlanta Streetcar. People instantly have an opinion ─ regardless of the facts.

Some call it a boondoggle. Others say it doesn’t go where they want to go.

Inevitably the conversation will go to the $92 million cost to build the 2.7-mile loop that connects Centennial Olympic Park with the King Center through the heart of downtown Atlanta.

When Atlanta Mayor Kasim Reed said the streetcar fare would be free through 2015, more grumbling followed. Won’t that even be more of a burden on taxpayers?

Journalist Maria Saporta wants to see the Atlanta Streetcar system expanded and sees the transit system as an asset to Atlanta.  Credit Mary Claire Kelly / WABE

Journalist Maria Saporta wants to see the Atlanta Streetcar system expanded and sees the transit system as an asset to Atlanta.
Credit Mary Claire Kelly / WABE

Hold on, folks. The Atlanta Streetcar is one of the best amenities to come to Atlanta in years. We finally are adopting a mode of transportation that increasingly is becoming the future for cities. Nearly every up-and-coming city in the country has a streetcar or is planning to build a streetcar.

Why? Because it makes economic sense.

Since the Atlanta Streetcar route was announced in 2010, there has been $840 million in new investments. And that translates into more property taxes and sales taxes being generated for the city.

The Atlanta Streetcar estimated that the $1 fare would bring in about $250,000 a year ─ and that didn’t include the cost of adding a fare collection system.

And for people who tell you no one is riding the streetcar, since it opened in December 2014, the Atlanta Streetcar has had more than 180,000 riders.

On a recent Saturday, the streetcar was so packed, it was standing-room only. Many of them were out-of-town visitors experiencing Atlanta with smiles on their faces.

The mayor said the reason the fares are remaining free is so the city can be strategic in deciding what technology to use for fare collection. That makes sense.

But keeping it free also makes sense ─ at least until the day when we have expanded our streetcar system to serve more of the city.

Let us increase the frequency of the streetcar to five minutes rather than the current 12 to 15 minutes between cars.

Yes. Let’s extend the streetcar a quarter-mile to the Atlanta BeltLine. Yes. Let’s expand the existing streetcar to the west along Martin Luther King Jr. Drive to connect the King Center with the Atlanta University Center. Yes. Let’s build the original vision of a Peachtree Streetcar to connect downtown, Midtown and Buckhead.

As we look to expand the Atlanta Streetcar, remember ─ it is not just for transportation. It’s a magnet for economic development.

And the cost to build, operate and expand the system is a bargain when one considers the economic benefits of riding streetcars into the future.

4 replies
  1. Brian Debonamour says:

    Why doesn’t the Saporta Report just merge with the City of Atlanta’s Press Office? The streetcar is a terrible waste of public money and will prove a drain on the public purse as long as it’s in operation. 

    If keeping it free makes such good economic sense, why wasn’t that the plan from the beginning. At best it’s poor planning; at worst  it’s more lies and incompetence.

    $840 million dollars in new investment?  Surely you’re not manipulate the public into believing that it all was a result of the streetcar. Anyone who believes that needs to  contact me about buying Piedmont Park. I’m ready to sell, and I’ll give you a good price. 

    For a different perspective, take a look at this article:  http://object.cato.org/sites/cato.org/files/pubs/pdf/PA699.pdfReport

    Reply
  2. Burroughston Broch says:

    Maria, surely you jest.
    “And the cost to build, operate and expand the system is a bargain when one considers the economic benefits of riding streetcars into the future.”
    The Streetcar cost over $98 million to build (what the City has admitted, probably to rise to over $100 million) – 50% more than was estimated. City taxpayers paid for all of the cost increase. Plus City taxpayers are paying $5 million per year to operate it with the present number of cars. Triple the number of cars to maintain a 5 minute frequency and you add capital and operating costs. And expanding it at the cost of $37 million/mile is not a bargain.
    Friends who have ridden it say its a novelty but slower than walking, as others have written in the press.
    All in all, the Streetcar is slower and more expensive to build, operate, and expand than MARTA buses.
    So why are you enamored of the Streetcar?Report

    Reply
  3. Guest says:

    No one ever accused Maria Saporta of actually being a journalist.

    However, this puff piece represents a new low in Maria’s portfolio of mindless pablum.Report

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

What are your thoughts?

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.