Type to search

Columns Eleanor Ringel Cater Main Slider

Half of ‘Lion’ would have been better than the whole show


'Lion' would be a better movie if director Garth Davis had stuck with newcomer Sunny Pawar and told the tale of a child who stumbled into a loving home. Credit: news.com.au

By Eleanor Ringel Cater

Recently, there was a full-page ad for “Lion” in the Sunday New York Times. Given that the film has been nominated for six Academy Awards, including Best Picture, Best Supporting Actor and Best Supporting Actress, this isn’t especially surprising.

What is surprising is, instead of the usual critics’ quotes, the ad features ringing endorsements from former Secretary of State Madeleine Albright, and UNICEF.


‘Lion’ would be a better movie if director Garth Davis had stuck with newcomer Sunny Pawar and told the tale of a child who stumbled into a loving home. Credit: news.com.au

UNICEF? That all but spells out you must be a bad person if you don’t love “Lion.”

I didn’t love “Lion,” ergo … oh well.

Based on a true story, “Lion” begins as the saga of a very little boy lost in a very big world. It’s the mid-1980s and five-year-old Saroo (Sunny Pawar) lives in India with his impoverished mom and older brother, Guddu, both of whom he adores. When Guddu sets off to find work outside their immediate slum, Saroo begs to go with him. Guddu reluctantly agrees.

However, things go awry almost immediately. The two are somehow separated at a train station and Saroo boards an empty train to nap and await his brother’s return. But when he wakes up, the train has traveled some thousand miles to the east.

Saroo finds himself alone in a huge, bustling city. He has no idea where he is; worse, he speaks Hindi and in Calcutta, where he’s landed, everyone speaks Bengali. The usual kid-on-his-own perils ensue, everything from child snatchers who regularly comb the streets for lost little ones they can sell to nasty people for nasty purposes, to a falsely enticing woman – she’s like the witch in Hansel and Gretel – who, well, does pretty much the same thing.

Madeleine Albright

Former Secretary of State Madeleine Albright is among those stumping for ‘Lion.’

Escaping her clutches, Saroo is put in an orphanage where they pretty much … all together now…do the same thing. But this time, the boy is lucky. He’s adopted by a couple (Nicole Kidman and David Wenham) who bring him home to live with them in Tasmania. They are dream parents, loving and supportive, even with a bad-seed second son they adopt after Saroo.

Jump ahead 20 or so years and Saroo (Dev Patel), though enrolled in school and in deep flirtation with a gorgeous classmate (Rooney Mara, given nothing to do), suddenly has questions.  Who is he really?  Where is his real family? Why should he stay with his adoptive parents, even though they’ve been unwaveringly wonderful to him?

The rest of the movie, which includes a big plug for Google Maps, concerns Saroo’s search for his roots.

Or, more likely, Patel’s on-going search for a Hollywood career.

The first half of “Lion” – the part about little Saroo – is spectacular. Pawar, a non-pro, is as affecting as any child actor in recent memory. He’s charming, stubborn, resourceful and resolute. He’s “Slumdog Millionaire” meets “Oliver Twist,” and he’s irresistible.

Kidman is equally compelling. But it’s not her story – though, in many ways, it should be, especially after Saroo has grown up and she’s forced to deal with his unexpected rejection of everything she and her husband have given him.

However, “Lion” is about Saroo – unfortunately, the adult Saroo who, as played by Patel, is moody, conflicted and yet somehow “heroic.”  Or so the movie insists.

lion, nicolle kidman

Nicolle Kidman delivers a compelling performance as an adoptive mother, but even she can’t overcome the weight of the final half of ‘Lion.’ Credit: revistavanityfair.es

Newbie director Garth Davis certainly seems taken with Patel – though not half as much as Patel is taken with himself.

Perhaps that’s the heart of “Lion’s” problem: Patel comes off like an Indian Richard Gere (incidentally, they co-starred in the pathetic “Best Marigold Hotel” sequel). That is, he’s absolutely convinced he’s more appealing than he is. By contrast, Pawar is so refreshing, so dedicated, so natural, you wish he’d grown up to be anyone except Patel.

No filmmaker – no artist, for that matter – wants to be told what he or she should’ve done. But given the distressing contrast between the excellent first and distressing second half of “Lion,” maybe Davis should’ve ended his picture when little Saroo, having escaped a Dickensian catalogue of horrors, finds safe harbor and solace in Kidman’s arms.

That’s not the whole story, but sometimes, half of a story can be exactly what’s needed. I mean, does anyone really want to know what Dorothy’s life was like back in Kansas with Auntie Em?


Eleanor Ringel

Eleanor Ringel, Movie Critic, was the film critic for the Atlanta Journal-Constitution for almost 30 years. She was nominated multiple times for a Pulitzer Prize. She won the Best of Cox Critic, IMAGE Film & Video and Women In Film awards. An Atlanta native, she graduated from Westminster and Brown University. She was the critic on WXIA’s Noonday, a member of Entertainment Weekly's Critics Grid and wrote TV Guide’s movie/DVD. She is member of the National Society of Film Critics and currently talks about movies on WMLB and writes the Time Out column for the Atlanta Business Chronicle.


You Might also Like


  1. Skuppy July 13, 2017 7:07 pm

    Good lord, what a mean-spirited review. Are you some kind of ogre?Report

  2. Barbara Mosley July 16, 2017 4:53 pm

    Thank Goodness – I am not the only person who thought the movie tapered off into self indulgent blather! Watching Dev swan about sticking pins in a map went on for much too long. The end was sweet and sappy, but leaves sooo many questions – what happened to the third sibling the two brothers left on duty that fateful night? What happened to the 2nd Indian orphan adopted? What happened with the faithful girlfriend????Report


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.