LOADING

Type to search

David Pendered Columns

Rural Georgia at risk of falling behind amid philanthropic pandemic relief efforts

David Pendered
Ben Hill, homepage

By David Pendered

Rural Georgia is at risk of getting left even further behind the state’s populated regions amid the pandemic. One key factor is that many philanthropies won’t donate to local groups that can’t produce audited statements and IRS designations. Bambie Hayes-Brown is seeing it first hand in Southwest Georgia.

Ben Hill County, home of the town of Fitzgerald, in South Georgia, reports having about 200 miles of unpaved roads and 152 miles of paved roads. Credit: Bambie Hayes-Brown

Hayes-Brown knows the non-profit world. In Atlanta, she serves as president and CEO of the Georgia ACT, created in 2014 as a statewide nonprofit housing and community development organization. Beyond Atlanta, she’s helped with workshops including one on micro business in Albany, a forum on fair housing and equity in the Southeast with the Atlanta Federal Reserve, heirs property and homebuyer education.

Hayes-Brown has yet to pry loose substantial dollars from funders to help with the pandemic in Southwest Georgia. She’s been told they want to deliver their contribution to a local entity that comports with traditional philanthropies – meaning, an IRS-certified nonprofit, one that’s complete with the capacity to produce for donors the W-9 tax forms and the annual 990 series of tax returns.

Not to give away the ending, but the situation facing Brown has become a drum roll resonating across rural America, according to Allen Smart, founder of PhilanthropywoRx, a consultancy specializing in rural philanthropy.

“There are rural regions of the country that are deeply impacted in ways that reach a national level,” Smart said in a webinar hosted May 12 by Grantmakers in Aging. “A good deal of attention was paid to Albany, Ga., in the Southwest of the state; native Americans and tribal communities in New Mexico and Arizona. It’s almost beyond comprehension, the impact, and still not meriting the attention that they both so badly deserve and so badly need.”

Here’s how Hayes-Brown described her most recent effort at trying to raise funds to benefit folks in a hardscrabble community:

Downtown Sylvester, train locomotive

The last steam locomotive to run on the former Georgia-Ashburn Sylvester-Camilla railway is a tourist attraction in Sylvester, established as a train stop between Brunswick and Albany. Credit: Bambie Hayes-Brown

Location – 20 miles east of Albany, a community that won’t be identified;

Situation – About 452 persons; 46 percent unemployment; 39 percent have finished high school; low income;

Brown’s account

  • “I put together a proposal to a funder and asked for laptops for children. Funding to put together a food distribution point – the town was like, ‘Hey, we have a community center, we have volunteers.’ Home repairs, $5 each, for senior citizens. And I was going to get masks from another source. I got a call from the funder who said this was the best proposal they’d ever seen from Southwest Georgia.
  • “The problem was that Georgia ACT is based in Atlanta. They were like, ‘Well, do you have a nonprofit in the area?’ The lady who called from the foundation asked if some of the churches could apply. You’re asking for 501(c)(3), a W-9. These are small communities out in the backwoods of rural Georgia. You don’t have that. …. So, the answer was, ‘No.’”

This pattern has a long history in rural America, Smart said. Family foundations account for much of the philanthropy in rural America. That may be an evolving situation, possibly declining, as their board members, increasingly, are spread across the country and can’t easily get a snapshot of local conditions in communities where local news is disappearing as newspapers and radio stations shift from more-costly local reporting to less-costly shows that are nationally syndicated.

One result in the pandemic is that COVID-19 cases in rural areas are too small, in absolute terms, to make headlines.

“While 15 cases doesn’t sound like a lot, in the gross sense of things, in a county of 25,000 – where there’s a closed school, workplaces, and nonprofits are struggling just to adjust to current conditions – it’s a lot and who knows what’s coming next,” Smart said. “Certainly, many barriers to health care access and nonprofit stability existed well before COVID-19. The impact on rural communities, and opportunities for rural funders, are the Perfect Storm of both challenge and opportunity.”

Cordele, Bambi Hayes-Brown

Bambie Hayes-Brown and her sister make repairs as they can on their heirs house in Cordele, now occupied by Hayes-Brown’s sister, two nieces and nephew. Credit: Bambie Hayes-Brown

The demographics of rural America haven’t changed much in recent years, even while the evolving U.S. society seems to leave rural America ever more distinct from the urbanized America.

Smart said some 60 million individuals reside in rural America. About 13 million are people of color. Major job sources are prisons, jails and meat-packing plants. Cultures in rural America vary widely, with some predating the formation of the United States by thousands of years. Rural populations are older in the South and younger in the Southwest. Rural adults are more likely to live alone than their counterparts in cities and suburbs. About 40 million rural Americans are without access to broadband, a recent study showed, though the figure used more often is 20 million.

“Rural America deserves a distinct look from the philanthropic lens,” Smart said at the outset of his remarks.

To resolve needs in the short term, Short advised that philanthropies consider using some standard responses to get more money into rural communities: Relax reporting requirements; pay forward existing obligations; convert program grants to general operating grants; contribute to funder pools.

In the long term, Smart said, the philanthropic community needs to step up to meet these evolving needs. Smart closed his remarks with this call to action:

  • “You may be the only entity from a leadership sector to actually be looking down the road, as everyone is consumed with the urgent demands of schools, health care, economic distress and all that goes with all that. What is the leadership role you can assume, or help other people, in looking six, 12, 18 months down the road.”

 

Charles Sherrod Civil Rights Park

The Charles L. Sherrod Civil Rights Park honors a leader of the Albany Movement, formed in 1961 to promote desegregation and voters’ rights. Credit: Bambie Hayes-Brown

 

rural philanthropy, covid copy

Rural America experienced a greater growth rate of COVID-19 cases and deaths than urban America during the period of this snapshot in April. Credit: Allen Smart via giaging.org

 

water tower, rebecca, ga.

This water tower still meets the needs of residents in Rebecca. Credit: Bambie Hayes-Brown

Tags:
David Pendered
David Pendered

David Pendered, Managing Editor, is an Atlanta journalist with more than 30 years experience reporting on the region’s urban affairs, from Atlanta City Hall to the state Capitol. Since 2008, he has written for print and digital publications, and advised on media and governmental affairs. Previously, he spent more than 26 years with The Atlanta Journal-Constitution and won awards for his coverage of schools and urban development. David graduated from North Carolina State University and was a Western Knight Center Fellow.

    1

3 Comments

  1. Avatar
    Julie May 26, 2020 11:21 am

    Great piece, David. The needs are certainly greater and hurdles to opportunity are higher in rural areas. As a native of a South GA town near where your article focuses, I can attest to the frustratingly small investments being made there. It’s a lovely area of the state, with generous, hardworking and gracious people. Success stories have emerged, like Richland Rum, Sweetgrass Diary and White Oak Pastures. But, so much more could be achieved. Think of it as a Napa Valley or Central Vally of Georgia, our breadbasket and center of agricultural innovation. Ag is our states’s number one industry, so why can’t we build on that? Family farms and their offsprings could retain their way of life, based on a fair return for an honest day’s work. The ripple effect would benefit and grow other businesses. And, investors could enjoy a fair return on investment. There probably needs to be incentives for this kind of investment, like opportunity zones. It could be done. Our whole state would benefit.Report

    Reply
  2. Avatar
    Dan White May 27, 2020 7:03 am

    Thanks for writing about the needs of the forgotten Georgia..Report

    Reply
    1. Avatar
      James R Thomson July 15, 2020 10:23 pm

      My mother, who grew up in Treutlen County, recently passed away leaving me a generous inheritance. I’m looking for a way to memorialize her that would provide a lasting benefit to this economically depressed county. I would appreciate any ideas or resources you could suggest to help me in my search.
      Thank youReport

      Reply

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.