Type to search

Columns Eleanor Ringel Cater Main Slider

‘Suburbicon’ – movie begun by Coen brothers 20 years ago, finished by George Clooney


Scene from Suburbico

By Eleanor Ringel Cater

That smell coming from your nearby multiplex isn’t stale popcorn. It’s “Suburbicon.”

Here’s the thing: All the machinations that go into making a movie usually don’t interest me. What counts is whatever made it up on the screen.

But a bit of backstory may be in order in this case.

Reportedly, “Suburbicon” began as a 1986 screenplay written by the brothers Coen, who’d just smashed their way into movie-lovers’ consciousness with their amazing1984 film, “Blood Simple.”


Suburbico poster

“Suburbicon,” as it was then, was more of the same. A wicked tale, equal parts blood and giggles. Something along the lines of Billy Wilder’s classic “Double Indemnity.” But the brothers were never satisfied with the end product and so the script sat in the proverbial back drawer for decades.

Along comes George Clooney, with his producing partner, Grant Heslov.  Apparently, they couldn’t crack the original script either, so they added another story — a kind of parallel plot focusing on what happens when the Mayers, a nice middle-class African-American family, moves into “nice” middle-class Suburbicon, a model of the modern suburban dream, circa 1959.

Reportedly, this part of the story is based on actual event that occurred in a Pennsylvania suburb in the late ‘50s.  It is, as you might expect, utterly nauseating. The cheerful mailman asks Mrs. Mayers if he can speak to the lady of the house and is taken aback when she says he’s talking to her (she’s not the maid??).

Even more sickening is some archival footage — a TV interview with a prim white woman who could’ve lived next door to the Cleavers (as in Beaver). She’s just, well, disturbed that “they” don’t try to better themselves before they think they can live wherever they want next to whomever they want.

Meanwhile, next door to the Mayers, there’s the Lodge family: Gardner (Matt Damon), his wife Rose and her twin sister Margaret (one blonde; one brunette; both played by Julianne Moore), and their young son, Nicky (Noah Jupe).

As the trailers have already revealed, the movie begins with a home invasion. The family is tied up and chloroformed.  Everyone wakes up okay except Rose. Already in poor health, she’s done in.

Because Nicky “needs” a mother, Margaret moves in.  Oddly, she dyes her hair blonde…

As so many Coen brother movies have reminded us, the best laid plans of anybody or anything rarely go as planned and that pretty much happens here. But while Gardner contends with loose ends and a nosy insurance agent (Oscar Isaac, unrecognizable and quite wonderful), the antipathy toward the Mayers escalates into mob violence.

The stories never mesh. In fact, they barely belong in the same movie.  It’s as if someone decided to remake “Double Indemnity” and cross it with “A Raisin in the Sun.”

The manicured lawns and Donna Reed coffee klatches are all too familiar.  Essentially, Suburbicon is one town over from Lumberton (“Blue Velvet”) and just downstate from any number of “Twilight Zone’s” perfect little hamlets.

The cast members do the best they can — especially young Jupe and Moore (who’s been here before in “Far From Heaven.”) But Damon’s fondness for characters in nerd glasses and sporting pocket protectors  (“The Good Shepherd,” “The Informant!”) makes his work seem all too familiar, too.

There are, however, two moments that I have to believe are pure Coen and I wish had been part of a better film.

One involves death by PB&J sandwich.

The other is a crazy exchange between Gardner and a town cop. “I thought you were Jewish,” the cop says. “Because of your last name.”

“Lodge?” gasps Gardner, who has a lot more on his plate than his religious affiliation.

“Yeah,” the cop replies. “Sounded Jewish.”

That’s the Coens, being not-so-serious men.

Eleanor Ringel

Eleanor Ringel, Movie Critic, was the film critic for the Atlanta Journal-Constitution for almost 30 years. She was nominated multiple times for a Pulitzer Prize. She won the Best of Cox Critic, IMAGE Film & Video and Women In Film awards. An Atlanta native, she graduated from Westminster and Brown University. She was the critic on WXIA’s Noonday, a member of Entertainment Weekly's Critics Grid and wrote TV Guide’s movie/DVD. She is member of the National Society of Film Critics and currently talks about movies on WMLB and writes the Time Out column for the Atlanta Business Chronicle.


1 Comment

  1. brainstar8 November 7, 2017 2:56 pm

    Hollywood’s dark side could very well be driving it into the dumpster. Many who would enjoy going to the movies are no longer willing to shell out (relatively) big bucks for the dubious honor of being lectured to – especially by producers, writers and actors they’ve steadily lost respect for. Viewer ratings for many entertainment-based awards shows, especially the Oscars, are mostly in decline.

    Like other media and those who consider themselves to be among the elites, Hollywoodland is in its own bubble. Is it so self-absorbed it doesn’t know it’s in decline? The Weinstein scandal just may be the tip of the iceberg.
    Will anyone genuinely care?Report


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.