Type to search

Guest Column

Don’t let the less fortunate carry most of the burden of budget cuts

By Guest Columnist HATTIE B. DORSEY, president of HBDorsey & Associates and former president of Atlanta Neighborhood Development Partnership (ANDP).

As we watch the toppling of leaders through civil unrest and violence in the Middle East, our thoughts must turn to what is happening at home.

For the first time since the Civil Rights movement and the Vietnam war demonstrations, our country is witnessing protest and rebellion by a generation who for the most part, are used to having it all. They believed that this country would never run out of financial resources, that we held the key to power and wealth, and was not subject to the harsh realities suffered by a majority of the world.

For too many it was easy to turn away from poverty, the effects of a lack of education, and the turmoil too often found in our central cities. This, of course, was the country that anyone who worked hard would be able to lift themselves up by their own bootstraps and if they didn’t it was their fault.

The sad part is the many Americans never would or could lift themselves up, and the hard reality was that many could not even find missing shoe straps.

The proposed budget revisions faced by the federal, state and local governments must be made, but they cannot be made solely on the backs of the poor and powerless.

Our President has proposed cuts in the new budget, the new House majority on Capital Hill proposes elimination.

We cannot blame domestic spending for the trouble we are in and allow the newly-elected majorities to eliminate the programs that provide emergency help in the form of heating, food, housing and medical assistance.

It was not the poor who led this country to the brink of insolvency; it was those who are found occupying the offices on Wall Street, the senior managers of major banks, and the officials we elected but who respond to the overtures of lobbyists with influence. It is far easier to provide tax cuts for the top 2.5 percent, than to put in place the resources that will lift many more out of poverty.

Placing the blame on certain entitlements is always a good way to rally the crowd who want to believe everything would be all right if certain populations did not exist.

The reality is the TV cameras recording the lines of people forming in the early cold mornings seeking help in paying the escalating cost of electric and gas – not only the long-time poor, but the new poor.

Some 10,000 people in our city alone received some form of utility help in the last three months and this does not include those seeking mortgage and rental support.

My sister who leads the Fulton Atlanta Community Action Authority (FACAA) served this population with a small staff and has 2,500 applications in process. The cameras have captured the picture of food banks empty shelves, and the plight of many sick patients packing emergency centers for medical assistance.

And while I and others acknowledge the need to reduce spending, it must be done in a way that will not put us in the same light as what we are witnessing around the globe. We are not immune to civil unrest.

We are now held captive by a new majority who swept into office because of fear – fear that the middle class and all its privileges are being swept away, fear that allowed states and municipalities to enact new immigration laws, fear that they too will be like the ‘poor’ they have looked down on because in spite to their work ethics, they too could not find employment. This fear is now spreading and political alerts surround us.

Do I have the answer? NO. But am I willing to sit by and not ask the question, or raise the issue? NO.

I believe it is time to speak up and out, to become the advocates for equality and justice and to not sit idly by while actions are proposed that will not only be detrimental to some, but can forever take away the hopes, dreams and ambitions of many.


  1. Burroughston Broch February 27, 2011 9:55 pm

    “We cannot blame domestic spending for the trouble we are in and allow the newly-elected majorities to eliminate the programs that provide emergency help in the form of heating, food, housing and medical assistance.”

    Ms. Dorsey, the tremendous domestic overspending resulting from the policies of our President and the 2008-2010 Congress are exactly why we are in the financial trouble we are in. Those policies continued will bankrupt this country and cause the end of the entitlement programs and most everything else.Report

  2. JC February 28, 2011 12:22 pm

    Burroughston, what you stated is what most people assume to be true, but it’s far more nuanced than that. Check this out (http://factcheck.org/2011/02/budget-spin/) for a fuller explanation of how non-defense domestic discretionary spending is contributing, and will contribute, to our nation’s debt versus domestic spending with defense included. Entitlements such as medicare, medicaid and social security will eventually go bankrupt regardless of whether we add more social program spending or cut all of it from our budget, because the driver is ultimately demographic change since WWII. Our country’ senior citizen population is only growing, and no amount of reduced spending on homelessness grants, CDBG, HOME, energy assistance grants and other services to poor people is going to change that.

    Cut all the domestic spending you want. At the end of the day our debt is still about our national priorities and how much taxes people are willing to pay to help those they don’t personally know.Report

  3. Burroughston Broch February 28, 2011 11:15 pm

    I read the article but don’t agree with your summary. Here are some facts:
    The total deficit for fiscal year 2009 was $1.42 trillion, a $960 billion (208%) increase from the 2008 deficit. The total deficit for 2010 and succeeding years is estimated by the CBO to be even larger.

    We cannot fund continue to fund entitlement programs in ever-increasing amounts while the President and the Congress continue to greatly increase spending in other areas as well.

    Our increased debt 2008-2011 has been about the President and the Democrat-controlled Congress’ priorities, not our national priorities. That was made perfectly obvious in the 2010 Congressional and gubernatorial elections. In 2011-2012, the Republicans own responsibility as well. The 2012 elections will tell the tale of whether either party has correctly gauged our national priorities.

    To be frank, I place a higher priority on senior citizens who have done their part and paid into Social Security and Medicare than I do on citizens and non-citizens who have not and will not.Report

  4. James R. Oxendine March 1, 2011 10:31 am

    An interesting and thought provoking perspective. Hopefully there are enough people with critical thinking skills who can address the issues facing the nation in a strategic, substantive and ,most importantly,equitable manner.Report

  5. Benjamin F. Logan, Sr. March 4, 2011 6:03 pm

    In reading Ms Dorsey’s article, I found it to be right on target. I agree with her that we need to curtail our excessive spending, but no one has mentioned how and why we needed to do that spending in 2008, 2009, & 2010. The spending was done in those years to hopefully stabalize our economy, and hold unemployment at a workable level.

    The major contributor to our situation is the out landish spending and trading that was done onWall Street, Mortgage Bankers, and over inflation of property. It was bound to burst somewhere, and thank God that we were able to somewhat right the ship from the runaway prices that were happening.

    Congress and the President need to come together and compromise on how to get the spending reduce to not hurt the poor who need our help, and not take away from us Senior Citizens who have paid into Social Security all doing our working days, and now expect to receive the benefits of it.

    Also, we need to stop depending on foreign oil and drill out some of the oil that is in this country in places like Montana and the Dakotas.Report


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.