Chrissie Hynde had already collected enough bad decisions, strange bedfellows, and close calls to fill a respectable rock biography before she got around to making a record.
An Akron native, she fell in with musicians who would become Devo, witnessed the National Guard killings at Kent State, then headed for London, where she wrote for the New Musical Express, ran with the punk crowd, and came close to marrying into the Sex Pistols orbit. A prospective band with the Clash’s Mick Jones went nowhere. Eventually, Hynde traded the typewriter for a guitar and formed the Pretenders with guitarist James Honeyman-Scott, bassist Pete Farndon, and drummer Martin Chambers.
The first two albums made the band one of the great prizes of the post-punk explosion. Hynde could take the Kinks’ gift for economical storytelling, Iggy Pop’s nerve, Patti Smith’s literary ambition, and the jagged guitar lessons of Television and the Modern Lovers, then turn the whole lot into something that sounded like nobody else. The Pretenders shared the neighborhood with the Clash, Blondie, and the Police, but Hynde wasn’t interested in joining anybody’s club. She had songs about sex, work, loneliness, and the trouble people make for themselves, delivered with a voice that could make tenderness sound like a warning.
Then the wheels came off. Farndon was fired and died of an overdose in 1982. Two days later, Honeyman-Scott died from a drug-related heart problem. Hynde was pregnant with her daughter, Natalie, whose father was Kinks frontman Ray Davies. In the space of days, she had lost two bandmates and been handed a responsibility that had nothing to do with rock and roll.
She could have walked away from the Pretenders. Instead, she and Chambers brought in guitarist Robbie McIntosh and bassist Malcolm Foster and started again. Learning to Crawl arrived in January 1984, but starting again isn’t quite the same as starting fresh. The songs still had to be played. The child still had to be raised. Life, with its customary lack of regard for dramatic timing, had kept moving.
“You with your innocence and grace / Restore some pride and dignity / To a world in decline”
“Middle of the Road” gets straight to business. Chambers’ heavy drums drive the song forward while Hynde’s chugging rhythm guitar lays down a garage-rock foundation for McIntosh to build on. His layered guitar parts, weaving acoustic shimmer into electric muscle, give the track room to stretch without losing its bite. Foster’s bass is melodic without getting in the way. “Back on the Chain Gang” turns loss into a marching song, its chiming guitars and communal refrain carrying a grief the band doesn’t need to explain. The song’s forward motion feels hard-earned, not inspirational.
“Show Me” is a different kind of tough: a mother trying to make sense of a brutal world while looking at her newborn daughter. Its buoyant melody doesn’t soften the question. If anything, it makes the stakes harder to ignore. Hynde hasn’t suddenly acquired faith in humanity, and she isn’t pretending that love can repair everything that’s broken. But this child will have to make her way through the world Hynde already knows, and that changes the terms of the argument. She’s found someone worth facing it for, and someone for whom facing it has become her responsibility.
“Thumbelina” puts vulnerability on the road, where independence gets complicated by the people who depend on you. The open road has always promised escape, but Hynde understands that leaving doesn’t cancel your responsibilities. “My City Was Gone” takes that argument home, turning Akron’s transformation into a hard-edged complaint about development, displacement, and the things progress leaves behind. Its rolling bass line has a jaunty swagger that makes the bitterness bite harder. Hynde isn’t simply mourning the place she remembers. She’s insisting that somebody ought to answer for what happened to it.
“2000 Miles” closes the circle with a Christmas song about absence. The echoing guitars and wintry atmosphere offer no holiday-card consolation. Someone is missing, and the calendar isn’t going to fix it. Across the album, the band balances jangly new-wave textures with hard-driving roots rock. The playing is muscular but never bloated, and Hynde’s rhythm guitar keeps the whole operation grounded while McIntosh finds room to roam.
Hynde made it harder to dismiss women who wanted to lead guitar bands without being turned into novelties or softened into pop decoration. Hole, the Breeders, and PJ Harvey would take that freedom in very different directions. Hynde also belonged to a broader lineage of sharp-eyed outsiders, from the Smiths’ melodic melancholy to Courtney Barnett’s dry, unsparing observations. She wasn’t handing down a blueprint. She was demonstrating that you could write about desire, disappointment, work, and the world outside your window, then plug in and play as hard as the subject demanded.
The cover makes a point of its own. Hynde insisted that all four members be pictured, a declaration that the Pretenders were a band rather than a singer surrounded by replaceable help. The title works on two levels: her daughter was learning to crawl, and the group was doing much the same after losing two founding members. Nobody on the cover looks like they’re waiting for a miracle. They’re back in the room, ready to get on with it, still carrying enough brass in their pockets to make their case.
Listen to Learning to Crawl on a cold morning, preferably before the day has had time to disappoint you. Turn it up enough to hear the bass lines and the guitars working against one another, not just the singles you already know. This is music for the drive you take because sitting still in a Ponce de Leon Heights bungalow has become intolerable. It knows the appeal of independence, but also what independence asks of you once the excitement wears off. There are people to look after, places worth defending, and songs that won’t play themselves. Sometimes forward motion isn’t freedom. It’s the job.
What Learning to Crawl understands is that surviving something doesn’t settle the matter. It leaves you with things to do. A child needs raising. A band needs rebuilding. A hometown deserves more than a shrug when the people and places that gave it character disappear. Love can make the world worth facing without making it any less brutal. The album never suggests that these responsibilities add up to a tidy lesson, or that meeting them makes anybody invincible. It simply gets on with the work.
That’s Hynde’s particular kind of optimism. She hasn’t misplaced her cynicism, and she hasn’t mellowed into somebody who believes everything happens for a reason. She still sees the absurdity, the injustice, the lousy deals, and the people who deserve a piece of her mind. But she also understands that walking away isn’t always an option, and that the things worth keeping rarely keep themselves. The Pretenders had lost two of the people who helped make them. Hynde had a daughter to raise and songs to sing. She didn’t need to find a silver lining. She needed to find a way forward.
Megan’s favorite song on this album is “2000 Miles,” which is a cozy, winter rom-com condensed into three minutes of what sounds like pure indie-girl yearning ballad bliss. On the surface, it feels like ice skating, watching fake snow float through a snow globe and the smell of sugar cookies in your grandma’s oven. But on closer inspection, there’s a sadness wrapped in the warm flannels and fireside glow. In tribute to James Honeyman-Scott, Chrissie Hynde wrote the masterful ballad after his death in 1982. Winter has a funny way of making the grief inside all of us feel even colder, and Hynde felt just that.
Perhaps in the same way we look kids in the eye and tell them Santa is on his way, we try to soften the reality of losing someone with the same courteous white lies. Instead of her bandmate and friend vanishing into some otherworldly dimension or afterlife, he’s only 2000 miles away — unreachable, but still close. And in the same way kids mourn the melting of their beloved snowmen every year, only to be consoled by the fact that winter will come again, Hynde promises she’ll see him at Christmastime. This is the most vulnerable pivot for Hynde. Listeners are used to catching her confident, femme fatale charm and rage. But in “2000 miles”, she’s quiet and sorrowful. She sheds the leather-jacket bravado for a winter coat and wears her grief on her sleeve.
Don’t miss the music video. And more importantly, don’t let the holiday themes scare you away from blasting this track all year long.
Wendell’s favorite song on the album is “My City Was Gone.” That filthy bassline and those Keith Richards-style guitar riffs were enough to get a high school kid to turn up the car stereo when the cassette he’d just bought at Camelot Music for the MTV singles reached this one. He’d come for the songs he already knew. Then Hynde showed up sounding less like the woman who could make a raised eyebrow feel like an invitation and more like somebody who’d arrived to collect on a debt.
The lyrics were angry, pointed, and socially conscious, but Hynde delivered them with an almost unnerving composure. She wasn’t going to waste breath shouting when a few well-placed words could make the whole room uncomfortable. Back then, I was mostly taken with the groove. The argument took a little longer to sink in.
I hear the song differently now, especially knowing that Hynde’s partner at the time, Ray Davies, had his own long-running ruminations on a London disappearing beneath the weight of change. His London and her Akron weren’t the same place, but they shared a familiar indignity: the people who made a city what it was rarely got to decide what it became. Hynde, though, has never been one to settle for merely being right.
When “My City Was Gone” became the theme music for conservative talk radio, she found a way to turn the arrangement to her advantage, extracting a six-figure licensing donation for PETA. There’s the full Chrissie Hynde package: the bassline, the complaint, the raised middle finger, and a practical understanding that even people who don’t share your politics can still help pay the bills. If somebody’s going to use your song, you might as well make them useful.
The Pretenders’ work can be found here, and their music is available on streaming platforms and in all record stores. You can hear their songs on SiriusXM’s First Wave, The Spectrum and 80s on 8. The Pretenders haven’t played Atlanta since 2003, though Hynde still takes the band on the road from time to time, the one constant through a succession of lineups. The names around her may change, but the songs still have work to do, and Hynde has never been one to confuse longevity with standing still. Some artists become part of a town’s history. Others never stop being the talk of whatever town they happen to be in. Chrissie Hynde has spent a lifetime making sure she’s the latter.
