LOADING

Type to search

Columns Maria's Metro

Environmentalists, builders seek more density without cutting down trees

Maria Saporta
Atlanta is seeking ways to protect its precious tree canopy. Here are trees along Ponce de Leon Avenue (Photo by Kelly Jordan)

By Maria Saporta

If Atlanta is to save its precious tree canopy, there’s a lesson to be learned from the adversaries-turned-friends experience between environmentalist John Noel and developer Adam Brock.

Ideally that lesson will help our city frame the ongoing rewrite of Atlanta’s tree ordinance, and we’ll find a way to increase our city’s population while protecting our trees.

Initially, Brock wanted to cut down almost all the trees on land at 2081 Hollywood Road in northwest Atlanta.

Property owners Wendy Hogg and John Noel filed an Appeal to stop Adam Brock from cutting down trees next to property they own (Photo by Kelly Jordan)

Adjacent property owners Wendy Hogg and John Noel filed an appeal to prevent Brock from cutting down the trees that also would have impacted their property.

“Their development was going to take up the roots that were part of the trees on my property,” Noel said. “We won the appeal, and they gave us 60 days to negotiate with Adam. It ended up resulting in a massive tree save.”

Noel, a former state representative who is now running for the District 4 seat on the Public Service Commission, said during the negotiation with Brock, they struck a private agreement backed by a $100,000 escrow if the developer violated the pact.

“We’ve gone from a 95 percent tree loss to massive tree preservation,” Noel said in a telephone interview from his home in Augusta. “We see this as a potential model upon which we can base future improvements. It shows a developer can get the same or greater yield if they are forced to think creatively.”

Brock

Adam Brock and Wesley Defoor talking at a community meeting in May 2018 about their plans for the Echo Street Project as Rev. Howard Beckham (standing) and James Arpad (sitting) listen (Photo by Maria Saporta)

In an email, Brock said he and Noel “have forged a friendship out of what started as a contentious relationship.  I believe there is mutual respect and understanding between us.”

It’s a surprising turn of events because Adam and his father, Steve Brock, have not been known as developers who protect trees.

In fact, Noel said he was suspicious at first because of his experience with Steve Brock.

“I wouldn’t trust Steve Brock any further than I can throw him,” Noel said. “He lied to me 15 years ago when I asked him to save one tree. He agreed to do it, and then he cut down the tree.”

But somehow the younger Brock and Noel were able to work through those issues and Noel said, “there’s a big difference between Steve Brock and Adam Brock.”

In his email, Adam Brock said he was pleased that through the tree appeal process that he was introduced to Kathryn Kolb, a strong advocate for saving Atlanta’s old growth forest.

Kathryns Kolbys expresses her concerns about the city of Atlanta’s new tree ordinance (Photo by Jeannette Yen)

“I have been working with Kathryn Kolb and Tierson Boutte (local Atlanta arborist), on a set of revisions to the current tree ordinance that would actually meet the goal of protecting trees, and ensuring replanted trees are done so in a meaningful way,” Brock said. “We have come up with a couple of ‘quick fixes’ we believe could have strong immediate impacts, and could be supported by the tree lobby and my industry.”

In Adam Brock’s mind, “the current tree ordinance rewrite proposal is bad policy.” It is “dramatically more complex” and it “increases cost by 1000 percent in some cases.” As a result, Brock said: “it has a completely disproportionate impact on lower income, less developed communities,” and “it would be a major setback for affordability” – one Mayor Keisha Lance Bottoms’ top priorities.

Kathryn Kolb, director of the nonprofit EcoAddendum, said proposed rewrite continues the unfortunate “transactional” process where developers pay the penalties for cutting down trees as part of their development costs. Doubling those penalties, as currently proposed, just increases those costs.

Instead Kolb said the new tree ordinance should be designed to save the most valuable trees in our city.

Kathryn Kolb said that 77 percent of Atlanta’s old growth forest is on single-family property (Photo by Kelly Jordan)

First, the ordinance should mandate a “pre-application conference,” where a developer or builder has to first consider trees before turning in building plans.

“The developer makes a commitment to what he or she is going to save,” said Kolb, adding that the appeals process is equally important as in the Noel-Brock case. “The tree appeal should also be done up front. It saves the developer time, and that’s when there is the most flexibility to change plans to protect trees.”

The second improvement would be for the city to prohibit developers from cutting down the higher value trees.

Kolb has developed a tree value matrix, which is a simple way to categorize the most valuable trees on a piece of land. If developers are given flexibility to alter their plans to save trees, the city could waive other zoning restrictions, like setback requirements.

“The entire crux of this issue is that developers and builders don’t want to save trees because they want to maximize the value of their development. At the end of the day, you can build more density without cutting down trees,” Kolb said. “

We need to develop a culture in the city of Atlanta that values our green infrastructure.”

What Kolb is proposing would result in “a much simpler process, and it answers the problem of the equity of tree recompense. It’s much less complicated.”

That’s what was most appealing to Adam Brock.

A map of the property that caused the dispute and then agreement between John Noel and Adam Brock (Googlemaps)

“We believe there are simple solutions to be had here, and that it is possible to allow for development and urban forestry,” he wrote in the email.

Atlanta City Councilman Matt Westmoreland, who chairs the Community Development/Human Resources Committee, had to postpone a work session on the proposed new tree ordinance because of the Coronavirus.

In a letter to “tree canopy stakeholders” on March 26, Westmoreland said the work on the rewrite would continue.

“Protecting our ‘City in the Forest’ is a critically important priority for Atlanta,” Westmoreland wrote. “In the intervening weeks, we will work closely with the Planning Department, community stakeholders, and the public to keep the city on track for final passage in August.”

This column follows last week’s column that disclosed tensions on a city advisory group between Steve Brock and Tim Keane, the city’s planning commissioner.

Atlanta is seeking ways to protect its precious tree canopy. Here are trees along Ponce de Leon Avenue (Photo by Kelly Jordan)

Tags:
Maria Saporta
Maria Saporta

Maria Saporta, Editor, is a longtime Atlanta business, civic and urban affairs journalist with a deep knowledge of our city, our region and state.  Since 2008, she has written a weekly column and news stories for the Atlanta Business Chronicle. Prior to that, she spent 27 years with The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, becoming its business columnist in 1991. Maria received her Master’s degree in urban studies from Georgia State and her Bachelor’s degree in journalism from Boston University. Maria was born in Atlanta to European parents and has two young adult children.

    1

3 Comments

  1. Avatar
    Paul Bolster April 14, 2020 12:13 pm

    What should we do when tree roots raise the sidewalk and make walking dangerous? The City could follow a practice I saw on route 99 out of Darian. The bikeway developer built wooden ADA compliant ramps over the live oak roots. Why not here in Atlanta.Report

    Reply
    1. Avatar
      Wormser Hats April 17, 2020 11:29 am

      Where there’s a will there’s a way: There’s an attractive concrete bridge over the roots of a grand old oak at the corner of Houston Mill and Adelia Place, just south of Lavista Road.Report

      Reply
  2. Avatar
    Atlanta Resident April 15, 2020 1:36 pm

    How many years has it been? I really can’t recall, has it been 15 or 25 years since Marsha Bansley first recommended putting the
    tree survey at the beginning of the permitting process? For residents new to Atlanta, Marsha Bansley also founded Trees Atlanta
    & she deserves numerous shout outs. Thanks also to those who continued to move this process forward.Report

    Reply

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.