Hancock County Courthouse – ‘Her Majesty’ – is reborn

By Maria Saporta

First in a two-part series. Next week: Sparta’s story a lesson for Atlanta’s Gaines Hall.

SPARTA, Ga. – Take note, Atlanta. The people in Sparta have found a way to cherish their city’s landmarks – showing what can be done when a community believes in preserving its past for future generations.

No building in Sparta tells the story better than the Hancock County Courthouse in the heart of this historic Georgia city. The courthouse is lovingly called “Her Majesty” – and she has become the town’s symbol of hope and rebirth.

Hancock County Courthouse

A reconstructed Hancock County Courthouse on Aug. 27 – two years after devastating fire (Photo by Maria Saporta)

On Aug. 11, 2014, fire swept through the courthouse – built between 1881 and 1883. Little was left of the structure except its exterior walls.

Only a year before, the Georgia Trust for Historic Preservation had placed the building on its “Places in Peril” list – almost serving as a warning of the danger ahead.

Sistie Hudson, who took office as chairwoman of the Hancock County Board of Commissioners on Jan. 1, 2013, had been working with her colleagues to try to repair the dilapidated courthouse step-by-step, starting with the electrical system.

“We didn’t have a decent sprinkler system,” she said. “I had just gotten elected and taken office. There was lead paint. Immediately I tried to start with the wiring.”

As evidence, Hudson showed some photos of the building shot two days before the fire. It was a building that needed to be renovated and restored.

On the night of the fire, she cried when she saw the building swept up in flames. Some people from the Georgia Department of Transportation came to direct traffic.

Hancock Courthouse

Courthouse consumed by fire on Aug. 11, 2014 (Photo: Hancock County)

“One of the GDOT guys said: “Take it down.” Hudson warned him to step back. She was not going to let the centerpiece of Sparta’s history go up in smoke.

“It was my mission,” Hudson said. “It burned for three weeks. The clock tower was so hot that the 800 pound bell melted.”

Then a series of serendipitous events began to transpire. The structural engineer – Carter and Watkins – determined the walls were sound.

About a month after the fire, steel was placed to reinforce the exterior walls. Architects from the nearby City of Monroe showed up with yellowed rolls of architectural plans of the Hancock County Courthouse. They had secured them in the 1990s when they were renovating the their county’s courthouse.

“The Watkins County Courthouse in Monroe and this one are sisters,” Hudson said. “They were designed by the same architect.”

Because the architects had the plans and because they had been involved in about 20 courthouse renovations in Georgia, Hancock County hired the firm of Carter-Watkins Architects – better known in town as Ben Carter and Joe Watkins.

“The process got a little easier when we found out the building was structurally sound,” Hudson said. “Things fell into place. We had to move very quickly to get the process started.”

Two months after the fire, a large sign declared to the community that the Courthouse would be rebuilt.

Hancock Courthouse

Sign proclaims the Courthouse will return (Photo: Hancock County)

Mark McDonald, president and CEO of the Georgia Trust, interrupted to make sure proper credit was given.

“Sistie is the one who pushed it,” McDonald said. “She took political heat for it.”

Hancock County also was fortunate that it had bought replacement fire insurance for the building from the Association County Commissioners of Georgia. After three different insurance adjusters had assessed the damage, Hancock County received a total of $7.2 million to reconstruct “Her Majesty.”

Ross King, executive director of ACCG, told Hudson the Hancock County Courthouse insurance claim “was the largest claim they’ve ever had.”

The project is defined as a reconstruction because it is true to the history of the building, but it has all the modern amenities of a new building. Of the $7.2 million, $1 million was spent on code compliance.

“We are totally compliant with building codes,” Hudson said. “We weren’t before. We call it a sliver lining of a really dark cloud.”

Hancock Courthouse

A sign says work will begin in January, 2015 (Photo: Hancock County)

Had it been up to the county to pay for the reconstruction, Hudson acknowledges it wouldn’t have happened.

“This county could not have afforded the reconstruction,” she said. “We would have had to move to a Butler building somewhere.”

On Aug. 11, 2016 – exactly two years after the devastating fire – Hancock County cut the ribbon of “Her Majesty.”

Hudson was in her office on Saturday, Aug. 27 welcoming about 500 people who had signed up for a Georgia Trust tour of the historic gems in Sparta. Naturally, the tour began at the courthouse, and Hudson was holding court as friends and fans entered her office.

“Isn’t this wonderful?” asked Hudson, without waiting for an answer. “It’s certainly a pleasure to go into work.”

She pointed to wooden bowls that adorned her office. “I wasn’t able to save my magnolias,” Hudson said of the trees in front of the courthouse. “But these bowls were made from their wood.”

Hudson also handed out glass bottles decorated with a design of the courthouse. She explained that a company in Sparta does the designs on perfume bottles, and she always looks for ways to promote Hancock County, which has been home since she was 2 years old.

Meanwhile, Hudson is not finished.

The county is turning the town’s old railroad station into a tourist center. That is near the house that Robert and Suzy Currey bought and where they have started an organic farm. Ironically, lunch was served on their property during the tour – local barbeque, but they couldn’t partake because they are both vegetarians.

Several other elegant homes and buildings also are available to  be restored. And Hudson looks out her office window and focuses on several properties around the Courthouse.

“I want the entire block to be redone,” she said. “I’m just a huge Hancock County history buff.”

Mark McDonald Sistie Hudson

Georgia Trust’s Mark McDonald thanks Sistie Hudson for her work to save ‘Her Majesty.’ (Photo by Maria Saporta)

Sistie Hudson in her office with portrait of her father (Photo by Maria Saporta)

Sistie Hudson in her office with portrait of her father (Photo by Maria Saporta)

Hancock clock towner

Comparison of new c;lock tower and old clock tower shows how carefully the Courthouse was redone (Photo: Hancock County)

Suzy and Robert Currey in Sparta

Suzy and Robert Currey in their Sparta home (Photo by Maria Saporta)

Hancock County plaque

Plaque highlights the reincarnation of the Hancock County Courthouse (Photo by Maria Saporta)

Hancock County Courthouse

Pretty as a postcard – ‘Her Majesty’ adorns downtown Sparta (Photo by Maria Saporta)

The second column in the two-part series: Questions threaten future of Gaines Hall

Maria Saporta, Editor, is a longtime Atlanta business, civic and urban affairs journalist with a deep knowledge of our city, our region and state.  Since 2008, she has written a weekly column and news stories for the Atlanta Business Chronicle. Prior to that, she spent 27 years with The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, becoming its business columnist in 1991. Maria received her Master’s degree in urban studies from Georgia State and her Bachelor’s degree in journalism from Boston University. Maria was born in Atlanta to European parents and has two young adult children.

14 replies
  1. John Wolfinger says:

    This accomplishment is even more amazing, in that Hancock County only had 9429 people in the 2010 census – and is the poorest county in the state.Report

    Reply
  2. Gil Robison says:

    Nice. My ancestor Elias Boyer moved to Sparta in 1809 and lived in a house still standing, now called the Rossiter-Little house. Sparta is an interesting small town with few people and many historic buildingsReport

    Reply
    • Vicki R Yates says:

      Just wanted to introduce myself as a relative. My grandmother, Mabel Hitchcock Ray’s father, Winfield’s mother, Mary Ann Boyer was the daughter of William Elias, son of Elias. I am a retired schoolteacher and I live in Milledgeville.Report

      Reply
  3. Judy Donaghy says:

    So happy to see this.  It is beautiful.  I visited the old courthouse about a year before the fire, doing genealogy research.  I was afraid it would not be rebuilt.  Congratulations to the people of Sparta who made it happen.Report

    Reply
  4. Robert Currey says:

    Thanks Maria for the nice words. Sparta and Hancock County have become a big part of the Curreys life and we are so glad that we landed here!Report

    Reply
  5. Loyd says:

    I am elated at this outcome. This is a late 19th century century architectural and social treasure. “Her Majesty” was originally part of a set of identical triplets. Not only was the Walton County Courthouse a sister but so was the old Hall County Courthouse in Gainesville. The Gainesville building was destroyed in the 1936 tornado and replaced by an interesting WPA Art Deco building. Unfortunately it has been marred by unsympathetic additions in the 1980’s. Thanks for the article.Report

    Reply
  6. scfranklin says:

    What a joy! I visited the Courthouse and a local cemetery 30 years ago with my children and their father, David. Their family roots are in Sparta as descendants of David Dickson, CME Bishop Lucius Holsey, Amanda Dickson and Julia “Dickson”.Report

    Reply
  7. HoraceHenry says:

    I strongly agree with you Chad. When Gaines Hall on the Morris Brown College campus was in flames, some people were saying, knock the whole thing down! Gaines Hall was the first building ever built for the then new Atlanta University. Historian and teacher W.E.B. Dubois had his office there. The building also housed the dining hall later for MBC and also served as a dormitory for the college’s female students in later years. We cannot let it be torn down. We must restore this historic building in Atlanta known as Gaines Hall. Let’s do Fountain Hall as well!Report

    Reply
  8. Rbjonesy says:

    Wow. I remember when I was a student at UGA riding around, driving down GA 22 and seeing this magnificent building on the horizon. Very impressed, and relieved, that Hancock County was able to build it back. Thank goodness for insurance. Frankly ACCG should automatically insure all historic courthouses in less affluent counties. And the Archives needs to make efforts to get all these old records scanned. That would probably be more of an effort than funding insurance!Report

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

What are your thoughts?

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.