Plan to demolish historic Lakewood Elementary School blasted as ‘shameful’
By John Ruch
An Atlanta Public Schools proposal to demolish the historic Lakewood Elementary building is being blasted as “shameful” by City planning staff in advance of a Jan. 12 review hearing.
The long-shuttered school at 335 Sawtell Ave. is at least 89 years old and is listed as a significant “community landmark” contributing to the Lakewood Heights Historic District on the National Register of Historic Places. APS wants to tear it down and replace it with nothing but grass after sales attempts reportedly failed.
The demo is not being well-received by planning staff with the Atlanta Urban Design Commission (AUDC), which will review the proposal, nor by the Atlanta Preservation Center (APC), a nonprofit that has long had that school and other APS properties on its lists of endangered historic properties.
“Staff stresses again it would be shameful if not irresponsible for a city to demolish such a building instead of preserving the history that it represents,” AUDC staff said in an internal memo prepared in advance of the hearing.
“This is a no-brainer,” said APC Executive Director David Yoakley Mitchell about preserving the school for reuse. “This is not simply a Dudley Do-Right fantasy. With these buildings that are listed on the register… you really have the vehicle to do some amazing projects.”
APS did not have immediate comment, citing a focus on preparations to return to in-person classes next week after another COVID-19 pandemic closure.
APS has a track record of historic, shuttered schools returning to use in praised preservation projects. Grant Park’s Roosevelt Historic Lofts and Academy Lofts are former schools turned into apartments. APS’s renovation of a long-closed school into the new David T. Howard Middle School won top awards last year from the Georgia Trust for Historic Preservation and the AUDC itself.
The AUDC staff memo about the Lakewood Elementary proposal suggests that there are many similar remake possibilities.
“Staff understands the abandoned building has become less desired because of the changing times of the area. However, any area can change, and this area is on an upswing,” the memo says. “It seems probable that another school will be needed in the area soon because of the rapid growth of all areas in Atlanta. Also, perhaps the building can be repurposed and be used as a shelter, recreational center or loft. There are multiple possibilities — anything but demolishing another historic resource in the Atlanta area.”
“The Howard School, obviously, was a massive success. The Adair School was a massive success,” said Mitchell. “We have a precedent for reactivation of these schools.”
“But we need to be fair to APS,” he added. “These [reuse proposals] have to be case-by-case. They can’t be blanket.” However, he said, there should be a demolition review process with such “gateway” items as to whether the building has a historic designation like Lakewood Elementary does.
Shuttered since 2004, the school is a two-story brick structure in the Colonial Revival style on a roughly two-acre site partly bounded by Sawtell, Charleston and South Bend avenues. Its current form dates to 1932, but there is contradictory information about whether it is even older.
The AUDC staff memo dates the school to 1915 with a 1932 remodeling. The Historic District filing — which was compiled in 2002, when the school was still open — dates it to 1932 based on its cornerstone, and adds that an interior plaque indicated a previous school of the same name was established in 1911, possibly on the same site.
Regardless, the building — originally known as Lakewood Heights School — is locally and architecturally significant. It was designed by the firm Edwards and Sayward, whose many significant structures in Georgia and the Southeast include the McCain Library at Agnes Scott College and the exhibition buildings at the former Lakewood Fairgrounds near the school.
APS’s demolition application calls for salvaging unspecified items from the building, then removing everything, including parking lot pavement. The site would be graded and seeded. It would then become a vacant lot surrounded by a 10-foot-high, chain-link fence.
APS’s contractor on the project is KHAFRA, an Atlanta-based firm whose website touts its “award-winning expertise in breathing new life into cultural and historic sites” with adaptive reuse and renovation projects in Alabama. These include the adaptive reuse of a water-pumping station into a museum and the renovation of two historic buildings at Tuskegee University.
Mitchell — himself the parent of an APS student — said that Lakewood Elementary is part of the bigger picture of APS’s inventory of historic properties and how preservationists might aid in their future.
“Whatever we can do, however we can do it, by any means necessary, we want to be an advocate for their adaptive reuse, for their reactivation into the community,” Mitchell said. “We can do better.”
The article never says WHY the school is historic? These abandoned schools are a hazard to the community. They bring squatters, drug-users, and criminals into residential areas. Renovating these buildings is way too costly, and many have asbestos. Plus, once the degenerates get inside, they steal all of the copper wire, rip up the plumbing, and just trash the building. Want a look? Take a flashlight and go on a tour of the inside of one of these things. You will have nightmares for weeks! I understand wanting to preserve history, but most of these school buildings are a lost cause. Trying to be WOKE and converting it into a “community center” is silly, stupid, and not economically feasible. Do that neighborhood a favor and knock it down.Report
This building is in OUR neighborhood. I have personally been inside of the building with flashlights and a contractor, and APS. THAT BUILDING IS GORGEOUS! Removing asbestos tiles and rewiring is nothing. That building was built masterfully and still stands strong to this day. Even empty and boarded up, it’s still beautiful.
The problem here is that APS doesn’t like the guy that wants to buy the property. He has a history of restoring and reactivating ransacked buildings. His methods for bringing attention to this building has obviously backfired. However, APS can have many more firms interested in restoring it. Perhaps they should put it up for auction with the caveat that it can’t be demolished.
The neighborhood doesn’t want it gone. Many people that attended that school still live in the area. The neighborhood wants to see it reactivated and now is the time to do it. We’ve gone from $40,000 homes to $599,000 homes. Our socioeconomic make up is very mixed and we like that.
We don’t need another vacant lot. How would that help continue the revitalization of our beloved neighborhood? If APS won’t sell the building, then they won’t sell the lot either. How many years will APS leave a vacant lot on us? Vagrants pitch tents on those too you know. If this proposed empty lot were ever to be sold (10-20) years from now, no other new building put in its place will have the detailing this building has.
It’s unfortunate that APS has stood in the way of good redevelopment plans of some of its other buildings in other neighborhoods.
Want to know more about why it’s historic? Look it up. Then you’ll find that the architects are the same ones that designed the Lakewood Fairgrounds and The Girls School. They did amazing work and both places were restored years ago.
Atlanta needs to curb it’s appetite for tearing down beautifully and masterfully crafted buildings and build up it’s pallet for restoration instead. If APS had asked the neighborhood what they wanted, tearing this building down would not have been rejected. We love this building. We want to see it restored and actively used again.Report
Typo:. It would have been rejected.Report
I attended Lakewood Heights Elementary School for 7 years. We had wonderful plays on the stage and dances on the floor in front of the stage in the auditorium. It was a school filled with wonderful memories! I think it could be used as a multi purpose community building! I have taught school in 4 states for 30+ years, and there has only been an auditorium in 2 of the elementary schools I have taught in!! I have school yearbooks I would donate if it could have some museum showcases in it. And I know other alum would also contribute to it. Please do Not demolish it!Report
Went to school there in the late 70’s. Tear it down, bad and horrible memories there. It’s served it’s purpose! Good Riddance!!Report